In November 1996, Calvary Ministries successfully lobbied the citizens of Durham to approve a bond referendum allocating $6.4 million towards the renovation of the old Lyon Park School. In October 2002, the Community Family Life and Recreation Center at Lyon Park was opened. First Calvary Baptist Church continues to spiritually, physically, and financially support this nonprofit organization.
The church underwent a massive expansion project in October 2008. First Calvary broke ground at the same location on Morehead Avenue and Kent Street to re-build a larger church building to include a sanctuary that will accommodate one-thousand worshippers and educational space. Construction was completed in January 2010.